Friday, May 29, 2009
Bollywood Influences apparent in Chadha’s EuroCinema
Even though she was born in Nairobi, Kenya, her family emigrated to Southall, England when she was two years old. Southhall, primarily a South Asian residential district, and is colloquially known as "Little India.” By growing up in Little India, where the population is over 60% Indian or Pakistani, and home to over 10 Gurduwaras, Sikh places of worship, it is truly the cross-cultural home of Indian and European relations.
Chadha has had several forays into the European cinema and Hollywood, yet she always picks British cinema over American when she has the choice.
With the newest fusion of Hollywood, EuroCinema and Bollywood, this trend will continue until it will difficult to tell which production continent a film came from.
Derek Bose, author of Brand Bollywood: A new global entertainment order, “Giant Hollywood production houses and studios like Walt Disney, Warner Brothers, Paramount, Fox and Universal Pictures are setting up shop in Mumbai. Already, India has become an international hub for animation and special effects. Much as the Gurinder Chadha’s (Bride and Prejudice) and the Deepa Mehta’s (Water) make films ‘with an Indian soul in a foreign body,’ the anxiety to reach out to a global audience at all levels cannot be overlooked. “
An Indian soul in a foreign body is the best way to describe the work that Chadha does. Her tribute to Bollywood in the short Quais de Seine in Paris Je T’aime, is wonderfully done yet before we can discuss her tribute, I have to outline a few of the genre conventions of Bollywood.
Bollywood films are mostly musicals, and are expected to contain catchy music in the form of song-and-dance numbers woven into the script. A film's success often depends on the quality of such musical numbers.
Indian audiences expect full value for their money, with a good entertainer generally referred to as paisa vasool, (literally, "money's worth"). Songs and dances, love triangles, comedy and dare-devil thrills are all mixed up in a three-hour-long extravaganza with an intermission.
Bollywood plots tend to be melodramatic. They frequently employ formulaic ingredients such as star-crossed lovers and angry parents, love triangles, family ties, sacrifice, corrupt politicians, kidnappers, conniving villains, courtesans with hearts of gold, long-lost relatives and siblings separated by fate, dramatic reversals of fortune, and convenient coincidences.
Several of these conventions can be seen in Quais de Seine. The scene starts out with what appears to be a gang of hooligans hitting on women. They are immediately denoted the “bad boys.” True to Indian cinema, one of them turns out to be good, and was just hanging out with the wrong crowd. We then see a young Muslim girl, quietly laughing at the boys.
When she falls, the wind is blowing, which is huge in Bollywood cinema. Whenever wind blows, it is an indication of love or the heart changing on a major topic. In Mohobbatein, the 2001 film, directed by powerhouse director, Aditya Chopra, wind is used as a symbol for romance. Whenever any character is falling in love, there is a huge gust of wind.
After she falls, the young Frenchman is helping her out, and asks her why she wears a hijab, the traditional hairpiece for Muslim women, she responds by saying, “When I wear the hijab, I feel like I have a faith, an identity. “
This quest for identity, is something that Chadha explores in all her movies. Bend it like Beckham has a traditional Punjabi family living in London, always trying to find their identity. It is similar to Salut Cousin! When Alilo visits Mok’s family. They have a vision of an idealized version of Algeria.
This is what Jigna Desai, author of Beyond Bollywood: The Cultural Politics of South Asian Diasporic Film, calls “Homesickness and Motion Sickness: Embodied Migratory Subjectivities. ’
She notes that Chadha has taken several cues from Bollywood in all of her movies. One of the most popular films of the nineties Bollywood cinema was the 1995 film Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge, also directed by Aditya Chopra. In this movie, a first generation Indian moves to London to seek a better life for his family, but he always envisions India, specifically his home state of Punjab to be something incredible, something better.
Desai writes, “Although nostalgia is pondered as a universal experience, that is, a structured feeling that is naturalized so that any subject’s experience of displacement from a past time and place is categorized as the condition of nostalgia, we may seek to differentiate between different productions of nostalgia, such as the patriarchal deterritorialized nation nostalgia of DDLJ.”
The young woman does that in Quais de Seine, she is seeking her identity in a foreign land.
After she gets up and walks away, all he has left is a picture of her, so he goes on a quest looking for her. This journey of a boy looking for a girl that he knows very little about is typical bollywood. While in Bollywood it is overstated and turned into a large musical production, the concept is still the same. This can be seen in Aziz Mirza’s 2003 film, Chalte Chalte. In this movie, the protagonist, Raj spots Priya and they have a brief meeting, from then on he is smitten and must find her immediately.
Finally, he goes to the mosque and waits for her there. In Bollywood, many romances have their turning point at places of worship. In the 2008 blockbuster, Rab ne Bana di Jodi, directed by Aditya Chopra as well, the main character realizes that she is in love while she is at the Gurudwara, a sikh place of worship.
The whole scene is very Bollywood until the very end when the grandfather invites Francois to walk with him and Zarka. In traditional Bollywood cinema, Francois would get harsh looks and cold stares for even touching Zarka but Chadha focuses on the humanity, which is a nice departure from traditionalism.
Overall, Chadha uses all sorts of elements from Bollywood, but they are simply muted and subtle. Through this connection between EuroCinema and Bollywood she is able to make a product that really does feature the best qualities from both worlds.
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
Bend it like Beckham clip for final
· plane leaving shows departure from english culture, flying away from the house
· from the bottom showing that we have no control over what happens
· all diagetic sounds
· when praying for the results, being filmed from above. from god's perspective, shows religiousness of family
· colors are significant
· dad- black and white- cannot see past wrong and right
· mother- english style robe over traditional indian clothes, shows her english exterior but is indian on the inside
· jess: wearing purple, ambigious color, not sure where she lies yet between english and indian
· placement of the family, centered- awkward for the viewer because people are usually placed on the corners of the screen
· everything is very gaudy and printed so the solid characters really stand out
· the shot is also very angular, showing us the stress of the situation
· when the mother hands jess the envelope, chaddha the director is acknowldging that the result of her exam scores is in jess's power not gods, because we see a point of view shot on the regular level
· you can still see guru nanak overseeing all of it, and it shows that religion plays a huge role int he family
· they value it more than anything else
· all internal diagetic sounds until
· angle returns to up when the results are good
· song begins. dream the dream.
· punjabi blended with english music
· while she is hanging colors, shows all the options in her future that her parents have offered, but they are all different versions of the same thing, everything is so bright and colorful, and when she sees the soccer bal it is the only thing that makes sense
· the way the camera is shot makes it look like purgatory, seeing heaven and hell
· the two empty chairs are symbolic of her mother and father who are still watching her so she is hesitant to make the shot
· her dark solid colors are in complete contrast to the setting and match the soccer ball
· the whole time she is toying around with the ball, "the chairs are watching her" the music is also loudly remixed between the english and the punjabi
· where there are no clothes represents the only part of her future that his uncertain and through that hole she kicks the soccer ball away, and picks up the clothes basket therefore signifying she has chosen the family, the indianness, to give up soccer
· from now on jess only wears color, true turning point
The Girl in the Cafe
Journal- May 27th
It was unexpected to see a Maghrebi and African cross-cultural exchange, when we were expecting the connection to be between French and Maghrebi. Everyone in the class agreed that it was messy, but that the point of the movie was respectable. Immigration is a serious topic but the film did not really properly address the harsh realities. By mixing genres, it failed to answer any questions and provided very few laughs.
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
Salut Cousin!
Salut Cousin, directed by Merzac Allouache, was not at all "delightfully zany" as Stephen Holden suggested to us in his 1995 New York Times Review. The movie was excruciating to get through and almost painful to watch as nothing happened. If a mood had to be assigned it would have to be something like stereotypical Parisian pop culture of the mid-90's, nothing else. The storyline was scattered and underdeveloped. What Holden describes as " the City of Light as an invitingly giddy multicultural swirl," is what he perceives the unfocused goal of the director. The one promising storyline, the romance between Alilo and the Fatoumata, a young black woman from Mok's neighborhood, is disappointing. The relationship which began of longing glances exchanged from apartment windows failed to develop into a more substantial relationship. This outdated film lacks charm and substance. The combination of whimsical plus reality did not work, as proven by the flying motorcycle scene, which made absolutely no sense at all. The sex cafe, was supposed to be a comic relief, but instead was awkward and unnecessary. There was no back story as to why he was there, because the audience was not given any context as to why he was actually there. When he began to imagine Fatoumata, it gave us the viewer very little insight to his character. All the characters were underdeveloped, and no emotional connection was established. The audience was familiar with Mok and Alilo's personality, yet could feel no empathy for them. Overall this movie was sloppy, unfocused, and slow, and definitely not a must-see.
Journal- May 26th
Yet film is an appropriate method to deliver this anomaly. Film is able to show the viewer the conflict between history and one's self. In Amelie, by using a combination of still photographs, motion picture in the present, flashbacks, and music, a certain mood and tone is conveyed. Furthermore, the European background is enhanced through film, one can see the architecture and weather and helps develop the mood. In the lives of others, the whole movie was dark with mostly gray and blue, it helped develop the somber seriousness of the film.